Creamy Old-Fashioned Potato Salad with Eggs and Pickles

There’s something about a classic potato salad that just feels like home. You know the kind—the creamy, tangy, perfectly chilled bowl that shows up at every barbecue, family gathering, and summer picnic. It’s dependable, familiar, and deeply comforting. This old-fashioned potato salad recipe is everything you want in a side dish: rich but balanced, hearty yet refreshing, and absolutely packed with flavor.

This version sticks close to tradition, with a few thoughtful touches to boost the flavor and texture. We’re working with buttery Yukon Gold potatoes, which hold their shape beautifully while still delivering that soft, creamy bite. We’re also bringing in hard-boiled eggs for richness, red onion and celery for a crisp contrast, and dill pickles for that unmistakable tangy crunch. The real magic, though, is in the dressing—a luscious blend of mayonnaise, mustard, buttermilk, and just a splash of pickle juice that ties the whole thing together with a slightly zippy edge.

I first started making this recipe after moving into my first apartment. It was the kind of dish that reminded me of home, especially during those early days when everything was new and unfamiliar. Over time, I tweaked it just a bit—adjusting the dressing ratio, testing out different potato types, and making sure it held up well in the fridge (spoiler: it absolutely does). Now, it’s a go-to recipe that I come back to over and over again. It’s simple enough for weeknight dinners but always earns rave reviews at cookouts and gatherings.

So whether you’re prepping for a casual meal at home or feeding a crowd, this old-fashioned potato salad has your back. It’s hearty, flavorful, and endlessly comforting—just like it should be.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

It’s the Perfect Balance of Creamy, Tangy, and Crunchy

This potato salad really hits all the right notes. The mayonnaise-based dressing gives it a rich, creamy foundation, while the yellow mustard and pickle juice bring just the right amount of acidity and zip. Then you’ve got the crunchy celery and pickles to add texture, with chopped egg whites offering a little more body and protein. Every bite is balanced, and that’s what makes it so crave-worthy.

Minimal Effort, Maximum Flavor

One of the best things about this recipe is how low-stress it is to prepare. You don’t need any fancy gadgets or rare ingredients. Most of what you’ll need is probably already in your kitchen. The prep is straightforward, the steps are easy to follow, and there’s no special technique required. And even better, it tastes like it took a lot more effort than it actually did.

Great for Make-Ahead Meals and Gatherings

Potato salad is one of those dishes that actually improves as it sits in the fridge. The flavors meld together, the texture settles, and everything just gets better with time. This makes it the ideal side dish for holidays, picnics, and family dinners. You can make it the night before and have one less thing to worry about on the day of your event.

It’s Always a Crowd-Pleaser

Let’s be honest—everyone loves a good potato salad. It’s familiar, it pairs well with just about everything, and it disappears fast. Even people who “don’t usually like potato salad” tend to ask for seconds of this one. And because it’s free of pork or alcohol-based ingredients, it’s halal-friendly and easy to serve to a diverse crowd.

Health Benefits

Potatoes: More Than Just Comfort Food

While potatoes often get a bad rap in health conversations, they’re actually a nutrient-rich food when prepared thoughtfully. Yukon Gold potatoes, in particular, are a good source of vitamin C, potassium, and vitamin B6. They also contain fiber, especially if you leave the skins on. When boiled rather than fried, potatoes retain more of their nutritional value while staying low in fat.

Eggs: A Powerhouse of Protein and Nutrients

Hard-boiled eggs aren’t just delicious—they also bring plenty of protein and essential nutrients to the table. Each egg is packed with vitamins like B12, D, and A, along with healthy fats and antioxidants like lutein and zeaxanthin, which are beneficial for eye health. Including eggs in this salad makes it more satiating and nutritionally balanced.

Fresh Ingredients for a Wholesome Boost

The addition of celery and red onion adds crunch, flavor, and a dose of antioxidants. Celery, in particular, is hydrating and offers a good amount of vitamin K and folate. Meanwhile, red onions are known for their anti-inflammatory properties and contain compounds that may support heart health. Dill pickles, though used in smaller quantities, also contribute probiotics when made through traditional fermentation.

Balanced Fats for Satisfying Meals

While this dish is undeniably creamy, the fats come primarily from mayonnaise and egg yolks. Using a high-quality mayo or even a lighter version can keep the fat content reasonable. Plus, the fats help keep you feeling full and satisfied, making this more than just a “side dish”—it’s a filling, feel-good meal component all on its own.

Preparation Time, Servings, and Nutritional Information

Prep and Cook Time

• Prep Time: 15 minutes
• Cook Time: 15 minutes
• Cooling and Chill Time: 1–2 hours (for best flavor)

Total Time:

Approximately 30 minutes active, plus chilling

Servings

• This recipe serves about 8 to 10 people as a side dish. If you’re making it for a larger gathering or want leftovers, it can easily be doubled.

Nutritional Information (Per Serving, Approximate)

• Calories: 320
• Protein: 6g
• Fat: 22g
• Carbohydrates: 24g
• Fiber: 2g
• Sugar: 2g
• Cholesterol: 110mg
• Sodium: 380mg

These values can vary slightly depending on the specific brands of ingredients used and portion size, but overall this is a satisfying, balanced side dish that offers a good mix of carbs, fats, and protein.

Ingredients List

To make this creamy, tangy, old-school potato salad, you’ll need a mix of pantry staples and fresh ingredients. Each one plays a key role in building that perfect balance of flavor and texture.

Main Ingredients

• 3 lbs Yukon Gold potatoes – Their buttery texture makes them perfect for potato salad. They hold their shape when boiled and provide a soft, creamy bite.
• 4 hard-boiled eggs – These add richness, texture, and protein to the salad. You’ll use both yolks and whites, but in different ways.
• 1 cup mayonnaise – The base of your dressing. You can use full-fat or a lighter version depending on your preference.
• 1/4 cup buttermilk – This adds tanginess and helps thin the dressing slightly for better coating.
• 2 tablespoons yellow mustard – Gives the dressing its signature tang and slight sharpness. You can sub half with Dijon for extra depth.
• 2 dill pickles, finely chopped – Adds crunch and tangy flavor. You can also use dill relish if you’re in a pinch.
• Splash of pickle juice – Just a tablespoon or so brightens the dressing and brings it all together.
• Salt and pepper, to taste – Essential for seasoning. Add gradually and taste as you go.
• 2 ribs celery, chopped – For that classic crunch and freshness.
• 1/4 cup red onion, finely chopped – Adds a pop of flavor and color. If you prefer a milder onion flavor, soak the chopped onions in cold water for 10 minutes before adding.

This combination results in a flavorful, creamy salad that hits all the right notes: savory, tangy, creamy, and just the right amount of texture.

Step-By-Step Cooking Instructions

Let’s break it down step by step so you can confidently make this potato salad from start to finish.

Step 1: Boil the Potatoes

1. Wash the potatoes thoroughly. Since we’re boiling them with the skins on, give them a good scrub to remove any dirt.
2. Place the whole, unpeeled potatoes in a large pot. Add enough cold water to cover them by about an inch.
3. Bring to a boil over high heat. Once boiling, reduce the heat to a gentle simmer.
4. Cook for 10 to 15 minutes. You’ll know they’re ready when a fork slides in with minimal resistance. Try not to overcook, or they’ll become too mushy when mixed.
5. Drain and cover the pot. Let the potatoes steam in the residual heat for 5 to 10 minutes. This helps dry them out slightly for better texture in the salad.
6. Peel and chop. You can peel them while warm (the skins usually slip right off) or leave the skins on for extra fiber and texture. Chop into roughly ½-inch chunks.

Step 2: Prepare the Dressing

1. Peel the hard-boiled eggs and separate the yolks from the whites.
2. Mash the yolks in a medium bowl using a fork or the back of a spoon.
3. Add mayo, buttermilk, mustard, pickle juice, salt, and pepper.
4. Whisk until smooth and creamy. The mashed yolks help emulsify the dressing, giving it an extra-silky texture.
5. Taste and adjust. This is the time to tweak the seasoning if needed—add more pickle juice for tang, or more mustard if you want extra sharpness.

Step 3: Assemble the Salad

1. Pour the dressing over the warm chopped potatoes. Warm potatoes absorb flavor better, so don’t wait until they’re fully cold.
2. Chop the egg whites and add them to the bowl.
3. Add the chopped celery, red onion, and pickles.
4. Gently stir to combine. Use a large spoon or spatula and mix carefully to avoid mashing the potatoes.
5. Cover and refrigerate. Chill for at least 1 to 2 hours before serving. This helps the flavors develop and the salad firm up.

Optional: Garnish with extra chopped pickles, paprika, or fresh herbs before serving.

How to Serve this Old-fashioned potato salad

Potato salad might be a side dish by definition, but when it’s made well, it can easily steal the show. The beauty of this creamy old-fashioned potato salad is that it’s incredibly versatile. Whether you’re serving it at a backyard barbecue, a holiday dinner, or just a casual family meal, it fits in effortlessly.

Serve It Chilled for Maximum Flavor

First things first—this salad tastes best cold. After all the ingredients have been mixed and the dressing has settled in, the chill time is what transforms it from good to irresistible. Allow at least 1–2 hours in the fridge, but if you have time to make it the night before, even better. The dressing soaks into the potatoes, and everything just tastes more cohesive and flavorful.

Ideal for Gatherings and Potlucks

This potato salad is perfect for feeding a crowd. It’s hearty and filling, which means a little goes a long way. Bring it in a large bowl and watch it disappear fast. If you’re hosting a halal-friendly gathering, this recipe checks all the boxes—no pork, no alcohol, and full of familiar, comforting ingredients everyone will enjoy.

Easy Upgrades and Presentation Ideas

Want to make it feel a little fancier? Top it with a sprinkle of paprika or chopped fresh parsley just before serving. You can also lay down a bed of lettuce leaves in your serving dish and pile the potato salad on top for a touch of color and presentation flair. It looks beautiful and feels just a little more elevated.

As a Standalone Meal

While this is technically a side, don’t be surprised if you find yourself eating a big bowl of it for lunch. With the eggs for protein and the richness of the potatoes and dressing, it’s surprisingly satisfying on its own—especially if paired with a glass of iced tea or a slice of crusty bread.

Pairing Suggestions

Now that your Old-fashioned potato salad is chilled and ready to serve, it’s time to talk about what goes best with it. This creamy and tangy side pairs beautifully with a wide variety of main dishes, sides, and drinks. Here are some classic and creative pairings to inspire your next meal.

Protein Pairings

• Grilled Chicken or Turkey: Juicy grilled chicken, whether marinated or seasoned simply with salt and pepper, is a perfect protein to pair with this salad. The smoky flavor of the grill contrasts nicely with the creamy, cold salad.
• Beef Burgers or Sliders: Whether you’re serving full-sized halal beef burgers or mini sliders, potato salad is a classic companion. Skip the fries and go for this salad instead—it’s lighter and more flavorful.
• Grilled or Roasted Fish: A flaky piece of white fish, like tilapia or cod, adds a light and healthy touch. The richness of the salad balances well with mild seafood.
• Crispy Chicken Tenders: For a kid-friendly combo, try serving this salad alongside homemade or store-bought halal chicken tenders. The crunchy exterior of the chicken is a great contrast to the soft potatoes.

Side Dish Pairings

• Corn on the Cob: Boiled, grilled, or oven-roasted corn with a touch of butter and salt is an excellent, sweet contrast to the tanginess of the potato salad.
• Roasted Vegetables: A pan of roasted carrots, broccoli, or bell peppers brings some warmth and color to the plate and complements the cool, creamy salad.
• Green Salad: Keep it light and fresh with a simple side salad—arugula, romaine, or spinach with a lemon vinaigrette adds a crisp element to the meal.

Beverage Pairings

• Iced Tea or Lemonade: A tall glass of iced tea, either sweetened or plain, goes down so well with a creamy side like potato salad. Fresh lemonade with a hint of mint is also a refreshing option.
• Sparkling Water with Citrus: For something bubbly and non-alcoholic, try sparkling water with slices of orange, lime, or lemon.
• Yogurt-Based Drinks: A salted lassi or ayran (a Turkish yogurt drink) is also a surprisingly good match, especially if you want a cooling element to go with grilled mains.

Storage, Freezing & Reheating Instructions

One of the best things about this potato salad is that it stores beautifully. Whether you’re making it ahead for a party or saving leftovers for later, proper storage ensures you keep all that creamy goodness intact.

Storing in the Refrigerator

Once your salad is mixed and ready, transfer it to an airtight container or cover your serving bowl tightly with plastic wrap. Place it in the refrigerator and let it chill for at least one to two hours before serving. For best results, consume within 3 days.

To maintain the best texture and flavor:

• Stir before serving to redistribute the dressing and ensure even consistency.
• If the salad seems dry after refrigeration, stir in a spoonful of mayo or buttermilk to freshen it up.

Can You Freeze Potato Salad?

Technically, yes—but with a few caveats. Freezing mayonnaise-based dishes isn’t ideal because the texture can change when thawed. The mayo may separate, and the potatoes can become mealy or watery. However, if you absolutely need to freeze it:

• Portion the salad into airtight, freezer-safe containers.
• Freeze for up to 1 month.
• Thaw in the refrigerator overnight before serving.

After thawing, stir well and check the consistency. You may need to refresh the flavor with a little extra mustard or mayo.

Reheating Isn’t Necessary

Potato salad is meant to be served cold or at room temperature, so there’s no need to reheat it. In fact, warming it up can negatively affect the texture. If you’re taking it to a picnic or outdoor event, keep it chilled until just before serving. A cooler with ice packs or an insulated bag works great for transport.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even though Old-fashioned potato salad is pretty straightforward, there are a few common pitfalls that can affect the texture, flavor, or overall appeal of your dish. Avoiding these will help you create the best version every single time.

1. Overcooking the Potatoes

If the potatoes become too soft or mushy, they can fall apart during mixing, turning your salad into mashed potato salad. To prevent this:

• Boil until just fork-tender.
• Let them steam after draining to remove excess moisture and firm them up slightly.

2. Using Cold Potatoes for Dressing

Always mix the dressing into warm potatoes. When potatoes are warm, they absorb the flavors better, resulting in a more cohesive and flavorful dish. Cold potatoes tend to repel the dressing, making the salad taste flat.

3. Skipping the Chill Time

This dish gets significantly better after sitting for a couple of hours in the fridge. Rushing the chill time can mean a salad that tastes okay but doesn’t have that fully developed flavor. Let it sit to give the dressing time to meld with the other ingredients.

4. Overseasoning Too Early

Salt can draw moisture out of potatoes and other veggies. If you add too much early on, it might throw off the balance. Instead:

• Season in stages.
• Taste as you go, especially after the salad has chilled.

5. Not Chopping Ingredients Evenly

Uniform size helps everything mix well and ensures that each bite contains a little of everything. Too-large chunks of potato or eggs can overwhelm the balance of textures and flavors.

Pro Tips

Want to take yourOld-fashioned potato salad from good to unforgettable? These pro tips will help you level up your dish with minimal effort but maximum impact.

1. Drain and Steam Your Potatoes After Boiling

Once your potatoes are fork-tender, drain them well and return them to the hot pot (off the heat). Cover and let them steam for 5–10 minutes. This step removes excess moisture and keeps the salad from turning watery.

2. Use Egg Yolks in the Dressing

This little detail makes a big difference. By mashing the yolks into the dressing, you get a silkier texture and an extra layer of richness that sets this potato salad apart from others.

3. Add Pickle Juice Gradually

Pickle juice is a flavor booster, but it’s also acidic and salty. Start with a splash, then taste the dressing before adding more. This lets you control the tanginess and prevent the salad from becoming too sharp.

4. Soak Red Onions for Milder Flavor

If raw onion is a bit too strong for your taste, soak the chopped red onion in ice water for 10 minutes, then drain and dry it before mixing into the salad. This removes the sharp bite while keeping the crunch and flavor.

5. Chill in a Shallow Dish for Faster Cooling

If you’re short on time and want the Old-fashioned potato salad to chill quickly, spread it into a shallow dish or baking tray. It cools down much faster this way, especially if you’re preparing it for a same-day event.

6. Taste Again Before Serving

Flavors mellow as the salad chills, so give it a quick taste test before serving. A pinch of salt, a touch more mustard, or a fresh sprinkle of herbs can make all the difference.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

When it comes to making Old-fashioned potato salad, especially a classic version like this one, there are always a few questions that pop up. Whether it’s your first time making it or you’re a seasoned pro looking to perfect your technique, these FAQs will help you troubleshoot and refine your dish.

Can I make this potato salad ahead of time?

Absolutely. In fact, it’s highly recommended. Making the salad a day ahead allows the flavors to fully develop and settle. Just be sure to store it in an airtight container in the fridge. Before serving, give it a quick stir and taste to see if it needs a little fresh seasoning.

Do I have to peel the potatoes?

Not at all. Yukon Gold potatoes have thin, tender skins that are totally edible. Leaving the skin on not only saves time but also adds texture and nutrients. However, if you prefer a smoother bite or more traditional look, go ahead and peel them after boiling.

Can I use a different type of potato?

Yes, but some types work better than others. Red potatoes or white potatoes are decent substitutes since they’re waxy and hold their shape. Russet potatoes, while common, are starchy and tend to fall apart more easily, leading to a mushier salad.

Is there a dairy-free option?

Definitely. You can skip the buttermilk or substitute it with a splash of unsweetened non-dairy milk combined with a little lemon juice or vinegar to mimic that tang. Also, make sure your mayo is dairy-free, which most traditional versions are.

What if I don’t have dill pickles?

No problem. You can substitute dill relish, chopped bread and butter pickles (for a slightly sweeter flavor), or even capers in a pinch. If you skip them entirely, though, you might want to increase the mustard or add a bit more vinegar for that tangy note.

Can I add other ingredients?

Absolutely. This base Old-fashioned potato salad recipe is wonderfully adaptable. Some great additions include:

• Crumbled turkey or beef bacon for a smoky crunch
• Fresh chopped herbs like dill, parsley, or chives
• A pinch of paprika or a few dashes of hot sauce for a spicy kick

How long can this potato salad sit out?

If serving outdoors or at a potluck, try not to let it sit at room temperature for more than two hours—especially on warm days. Use a chilled serving dish or place the salad bowl in a larger bowl of ice to help keep it cool.

Can I freeze leftovers?

While technically possible, it’s not ideal. The texture of the potatoes and the mayonnaise-based dressing can change when frozen and thawed. If you must freeze it, do so in small, airtight portions and be aware that the salad may separate or become watery after thawing.

What if the salad seems too dry?

If the salad looks or feels dry after chilling, just stir in an extra spoonful of mayonnaise or a splash of buttermilk to revive the texture. This is especially common after a day or two in the fridge.

How do I keep the salad from becoming too salty?

Remember that ingredients like pickles, mustard, and even mayonnaise can contain salt. Start with a small amount and taste as you go. It’s much easier to add more seasoning than to fix an over-salted dish.

Conclusion & Call to Action

There’s a reason why Old-fashioned potato salad has stood the test of time—it’s simple, satisfying, and packed with flavor. This creamy old-fashioned version, with its perfectly cooked Yukon Gold potatoes, rich hard-boiled eggs, and tangy dressing, is everything a great potato salad should be. It’s a dish that doesn’t need frills to impress. Instead, it leans on balance, texture, and tradition to deliver something truly special.

Whether you’re making it for your family on a quiet weekend, bringing it to a festive cookout, or adding it to a holiday spread, this recipe is one you’ll come back to again and again. It’s flexible enough to suit your tastes—you can make it herby, spicy, or extra creamy—and it’s reliable in a way that few side dishes are. No one’s ever disappointed when they see a bowl of potato salad on the table.

So now it’s your turn. I hope you’ll give this recipe a try and make it your own. Let it be the dish that brings a little extra comfort to your dinner table or that earns a permanent spot in your summer BBQ lineup. And when you do make it, don’t forget to share your creation. Snap a photo, tag me on social media, or drop a comment below with your own personal twist—I’d love to hear how you made it your own.

Recipes like this one are meant to be shared, adapted, and passed down. And who knows? Maybe this will become your family’s go-to potato salad recipe. I know it’s certainly earned that spot in mine.

Print